Menu
Flavors
Soft Ice Cream
Vanilla
Chocolate
Vanilla & Chocolate Twist
Italian Ice
Blue Raspberry (TR)
Cherry (TR)
Lemon (TR)
Dole Whip
Cherry
Pineapple
Cherry & Pineapple Twist
Hard Ice Cream
Almond Joy (TR)
Banana
Black Raspberry
Butter Pecan
Cake Batter
Cannoli
Cappuccino Explosion
Carmelinda
Cherry Vanilla
Chocolate
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Chip Mint
Chocolate Marshmallow (TR, PT, MS)
Chocolate Overload
Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch
Christmas Mint
Coconut (TR)
Coffee
Cookie Dough
Cotton Candy
Cupcake (TR)
Dark Side of the Moon
Devil Dog
Flavor of Love NEW
Golden Grammy
Grandma's Apple Pie
Grasshopper (TR)
Key Lime Pie (TR)
Lemon Sherbert
Mississippi Mud Pie
New York Cheesecake
Nutella Graham
Ooey Gooey Oreo
Orange Sherbet
Orange Swirl
Oreo / Cookies and Cream
Peanut Butter Overload
Pistachio
Razzle Dazzle
Robert Brownie Jr.
Rocky Road (AB, TR)
Salty Sea Captain
Sticky Fingers
Strawberry
Vanilla
Vanilla Peanut Butter Crunch
Watermelon Sherbet
(AB) Aberdeen Exclusive
(MS) Manasquan Exclusive
(PT) Point Pleasant Exclusive
(TR) Toms River Exclusive
Toppings
Black Cherries
Brownie Bites
Butterfingers
Caramel
Chocolate Chips*
Chocolate Crunch*
Chocolate Sprinkles*
Chocolate Syrup
Cone Dip*
Cookie Dough
Fudge
Heath Bar
M&M's
Malt
Marshmallow Syrup
Nutella
Oreos
Peanut Butter Sauce
Peanuts*
Pineapples
Rainbow Sprinkles*
Red Cherries
Sno-Caps / Nonpareils
Strawberries
Swedish Fish
Toasted Coconut*
Vanilla Crunch*
Wet Walnuts
Whipped Cream
White Coconut
* = Available on Cones
Sizes & Prices
Cups
Small
Medium
Large
Price
(Soft)
Price
(Hard)
$3.84
$5.15
$6.35
$4.16
$5.60
$6.78
Cones
Small
Large
^ Flat bottom wafer and pointed wafer cones available in all sizes. Sugar cone only available in small.
Price
(Soft)
Price
(Hard)
$3.84
$5.15
$4.16
$5.60
Sundae Cups
Small
Medium
Large
$5.05
$6.10
$7.42
$5.49
$6.46
$7.88
^ All come with one topping, whipped cream, and a cherry
Shakes
Small
Large
Extra Thick Small
Extra Thick Large
$4.59
$6.35
$4.89
$6.93
$5.23
$6.99
$5.62
$7.65
Waffle
Dipped Waffle
^ Dipped waffle cone options include cone dip, cone dip with rainbow sprinkles, and cone dip with chocolate crunch
$5.40
$5.86
$6.28
$6.73
Shake Floats
Small
Large
Extra Thick Small
Extra Thick Large
$4.66
$6.60
$5.20
$7.09
$5.36
$7.29
$5.74
$7.29
^ All come with cannoli cream, cannoli shells, and chocolate syrup
Cannoli Sundaes
Small
Large
$6.20
$7.80
$6.70
$8.40
Flurries
Small
Large
$5.85
$7.25
Price
^ Both come with up to three toppings
Egg Creams
Small
Large
^ Available in Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Coffee, and Banana
$1.40
$2.31
Italian Ice
Small
Medium
Large
$3.00
$4.34
$5.50
Banana Split
^ Comes with up to three toppings, whipped cream, and a cherry
Lava Cake
$9.35
$10.25
$6.20
$7.80
$6.70
$8.40
^ Comes with warm chocolate lava cake and one topping
Small
Large
Root Beer & Cola Floats
Small
Large
^ Available with Root Beer, Coke, and Diet Coke
Ice Cream Sodas
Small
Large
^ Available in Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Coffee, and Banana
Toppings
Toppings
Sprinkles & Cone Toppings
Note: All prices are listed before tax
$0.90
$0.55
$4.00
$5.59
$4.75
$6.30
$4.75
$6.30
$4.00
$5.59
Butter Cake - NEW
$7.80
$8.40
Cakes
Size
Servings
Price
Log
Football
7" Round
8" Square
9" Round
Small Sheet
Medium Sheet
Large Sheet
8 - 10
8 - 10
8 - 10
10 - 12
12 - 15
15 - 20
20 - 26
26 - 36
$27.00
$23.00
$23.00
$27.55
$32.05
$41.20
$47.75
$63.25
Note: Log Cakes and Large Sheets must be specialty orders. Prices are based on our standard stock cakes.
Standard Stock Cakes
SPECIALTY
Cakes
Looking to order a specialty cake? Give any of our stores a call at least a day in advance and we can help create a cake that's right for you!
Balloons
Confetti
Daisy
Dots
Football (7" Only)
Penguin (7" Only)
Pre-Made Specialty Stock Cakes
7" Standard w/ Fudge & Chocolate Crunch
7" Standard w/ Fudge & No Crunch
7" All Vanilla w/ Chocolate Crunch
7" All Vanilla w/ Vanilla Crunch
7" All Chocolate w/ Chocolate Crunch
8" Standard w/ Fudge & Chocolate Crunch
9" Standard w/ Fudge & Chocolate Crunch
Football Cake
7" Balloons
7" Daisies
Football Cake
1/9
Specialty Cake Options
When designing a specialty cake you may customize a variety of things...
The Flavors
The flavors is where most of the delicious taste comes from. You know what they say: "It's what on the inside that counts!" You can replace the chocolate, vanilla, or both with any of our hard flavors.
The Middle
Most of our stock cakes come with a layer of chocolate crunch, but you make the middle fudge and crunch, just fudge, or even any of our toppings.
The Design
The design is the finishing touch on any cake, so it's important to make it look good! You can customize the outside and the trim as well as what's written on top and in what color. You can even have one of our cake decorators draw something for you!
Take Home
Ice Cream Saucers / Sandwiches
Standard Ice Cream Saucers
All Vanilla
Half Chocolate Half Vanilla
Chocolate and Vanilla Twist
Deluxe Ice Cream Saucers
Oreo
Chocolate w/ Chocolate Sprinkles
Vanilla w/ Rainbow Sprinkles
Chipwiches
Price
(Single Saucer)
Standard
Deluxe
$1.95
$2.05
Price
(Single)
Price
(4 Pack)
Sundae Bars
$10.00
$2.60
Bonnets
All Vanilla
Half Chocolate Half Vanilla
$9.90
$9.90
Price
(6 Pack)
Mini Sundaes
$11.00
Peanut Butter Cups
$11.00
Sprinkle Cups
All Vanilla
Two Chocolate & Four Vanilla
$10.50
$10.50
Sprinkle Cups
Peanut Butter Pie
Mini Sundaes
Sprinkle Cups
1/8
Price
(6 Pack)
$10.45
$12.55
Pies
Oreo Brownie Pie
Peanut Butter Brownie Pie
Dixie Cups
All Vanilla
Chocolate and Vanilla Twist
Price
$19.35
$19.35
Price
(8 Pack)
$9.60
$9.60
Price
(Soft)
Price
(Hard)
Pints
Quarts
1/2 Gallons
$6.65
$10.00
$14.80
$7.20
$10.75
$15.55
Allergy Information
Although every precaution will be taken in the preparation of your order, we are not a peanut or tree-nut free facility and therefore CANNOT guarantee the peanut or tree-nut safety of your purchase.
by Owen MacCarrick